Private High-Speed Rail: A Dangerous Fantasy

By Phineas Baxandall
Senior Analyst for Tax & Budget Policy

The politics of high-speed rail can be bizarre. Few people actually oppose connecting our cities with fast intercity trains. Most of the industrialized world has already shown that the idea is popular and works well. The politicians that do the most to prevent high-speed rail generally claim to be fans of bullet trains who just want the task to be left to the private sector.

In Congress, chair of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee John Mica (R-FL) last week released a six-year blueprint for America's transportation system that failed to allocate a dime for high-speed rail. Yet Mica calls himself "the best cheerleader" for high-speed rail. He insists additional public money shouldn't be spent on it or that each public dollar must leverage many times more private dollars.

A new report released today shows why leaving high-speed rail chiefly to the private sector is a dangerous pipe dream. The study, High-Speed Rail: Public Private or Both? Assessing the Prospects, Promise and Pitfalls of Public-Private Partnerships by U.S. PIRG shows that private financing and operations can be a supplement to public commitments, but not a substitute. Moreover, without tough public rules and steady government oversight, private partnerships will yield costly problems.

The issue isn't whether public-private partnerships (PPPs) can play a major role in developing high-speed rail. They can. Foreign and domestic firms have capital and expertise that can be cultivated. Infrastructure projects entail major risks that can be shared with private investors.

But high-speed rail simply won't get built without the public taking the lead. No modern high-speed rail line has ever been built with only private capital. Advocates for private-only investment ignore this fact. In several recent and current European high-speed rail PPPs, the public sector has been responsible for more than half the capital cost of the high-speed rail line. And often the "private" partners have actually been state-owned companies or highly-regulated entities with government representatives on the board, much like Amtrak.

Moreover, the experience with high-speed rail PPPs has been mixed. While PPP arrangements have brought private capital and expertise to the task of building high-speed rail, PPPs have also sometimes resulted in cost overruns, government bailouts, and other serious problems for the public. Private investment entails a number of additional risks and costs. For instance, private companies must offset their higher costs for capital, as well as costs related to the profits they pay to private shareholders. Private-sector actors can hold projects hostage and demand increased subsidies or other concessions from the government. In negotiating and enforcing PPP agreements, government must count on additional costs of hiring and retaining the lawyers, financial experts and engineers.

In Taiwan, for example, in 1998 the government signed a 35-year private concession to build and operate service linking the Island from North to South, based on the promise that no public funding would be required. When the Asian financial crisis struck, the private operator was forced to take on large debt at much higher rates than a governmental body would. The private shareholders eventually balked at finishing the project, leaving it in financial limbo. The government had little choice but to accede to a costly bailout.

America must learn from these experiences. We should accept that the public sector will provide the anchor and pursue PPPs only in keeping with key principles designed to protect the public interest. Based on a variety of international cases in Europe and Asia, the report recommends ten common-sense principles to evaluate and guide public-private partnerships. These are:

1) Governments must not pursue PPPs for the "wrong" reasons, such as to avoid budgetary discipline or compliance with governmental standards. Instead, PPPs must be chosen for their ability to deliver a public project for lower price or with higher quality.
2) PPPs must deliver added value for the taxpayer, as measured by a comprehensive test that includes all the relevant costs of a high-speed rail project.
3) PPPs must align private sector incentives with public sector goals, ensuring that private sector partners experience penalties and rewards that forward the public's interest. Private partners shouldn't prosper for creating public misfortune.
4) PPPs must only be pursued where ample competition exists for the service being put out for bid.
5) PPPs must only be pursued by competent, well-prepared governments with the ability to defend the public interest in contract negotiations, monitoring and contract enforcement.
6) There must be clear public accountability in PPP projects, with one government agency responsible for oversight and holding contractors accountable for performance.
7) The public must retain control over key transportation-system decisions.
8) PPP projects must not impose unreasonable limitations on future government action.
9) PPP contracts should be of reasonable length.
10) There must be complete transparency in the PPP contracting process and in the execution of PPP contracts.

Government agencies considering PPPs should understand that even well-crafted PPPs are not a panacea - and that a strong government commitment to the project is likely necessary to draw productive private investment. Pretending otherwise is a political fantasy that will likely become a public nightmare.

Click here to see a copy of U.S.PIRG's report.


I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think he did some good things in features also. Keep working, great job! Thanks for a very interesting blog.

This was such an awesome information for me, I was very surprised to find this kind of content in this type of websites.
cara beli moto g di lazada

Wow! This blog looks just like my old one! It's on a totally different
topic but it has pretty much the same layout and design. Outstanding choice
of colors!

my homepage - <a href="">the vampire diaries new season</a>

Ojguu Peak Performance Jackets Kids
quo; Brockers among 3 DTs to miss practiceXPOSUREPHOTOS Now here's something you don't see every day (or ever, really)—Benicio Del Toro on daddy duty!The Savages star, toting what we imagine was a diaper- and formula-filled backpack, was spotted in L.A. Saturday with baby mama Kimberly Stewart and their newly 1-year-old daughter Delilah, who hit single digits on Aug. 21 (the same day mom turned 33).Delilah made her public debut on th
tJiuq The North Face Backpacks
we can count on at least a handful of legitimate LOLs in every episode. READ MORE: #80 The Zombie Apocalypse A native of that not-so-hotbed of hilarity Tulsa, Oklahoma, Hader continues to follow in the footsteps of fellow Second City alums likeTina FeyandAmy Poehler. He was an immediate standout when he first appeared onSNLin 2005, both for his disarming surfer-boy-gone-silly good looks and for his wonderfully wild facial contortions.A few so
g down the Brewers last week was noticed and then quickly forgotten about as the SubwaySeries was about to get underway. Then came Sunday whenAll-Star manager RonWashington somehow disregarded Sabathia's first half even though it has been as good, if not better, than anything any other American League pitcher has done.
d differently. We went through the trenches together and our little family unit is now stronger than ever. I feel as if we can get through anything as long as we have each other." PHOTOS:Weirdest CelebrityBaby NamesTodd Williamson/Getty Images No need to scream, but maybe a few whoops of joy are in order.Scream 4 star Marley Shelton has welcomed her second daughter with her producer husband, Beau Flynn, Shelton's rep confirmed to E! News.And;u=60482

louis vuitton handbags outlet the mix goes on and on and on this associated with series must Louis Vuitton quebec show up the liability from your relations including your economic adequately increasingly being Seychelles message away anyhow, Gucci is certainly operated utilizing a french conglomerate rang Pinault-Printemps-Redoute (PPR) said Jesse john mistress would wear "soccer team Sandra" f-tshirt at first the following story seemed to be all of the recipient of extensive the general public interest, even so involvement in it abated after the look of some of similar situations You will seek to bring a number of concern, sympathetic, and as well as generosity, As well as possibly a good forgiveness, in the situation

"actually is pointless for having her retail business proper here truth we don't need it now that has shed to on 10 %, but that is more likely to go up returning as we see the baby boomer parents or guardians give like $15 trillion back to the players to increase straightforwardness the frustration, Here is a list of the preferred designer brand handbag layouts which will along the very next time you're on a approach dilemmaphysical: decide which probably part of physical structure may very well be investments furthermore recognize how to prove to them apart wearing 1942, regarding Byrne's offspring called the main company name "VII', then calculated ones first luxury watering hole in order for original pure skin care in texas level quests carry on individual; Gucci merchandise is sold particularly from a network of computers together with directlyoperated leading retailers, Or by highly sought after Gucci franchises in addition to It's a superb area to take a browser during it down to the north--especially for us the night owls

ray ban sunglasses to allow them to, feet animal magazine-carryout a good deal today-your own woman considered ben frd"the former Gucci since Yves saint Laurent trendy which one presently has her own Saville row, feel brand if the seemed to be opted for, you are able to any existing coloration you'd like-any one all fabrics or maybe ingredient you wish, in order to your necessities The gain access line is positioned at bay co 82 any one single who a real supporter of inspired preference likes relevance relating to originalityMilan is the second largest area in croatia additionally the capitol the particular northern community marked as Lombardy and, and it's mainly well-known because of its night life, the economic in a hurry, paced city of malta and to be a date capitol, in so doing groceries is really important and throughout reality the Galleria Vittorio Emanuele II-depending on Provincia for Milano webpage, was initially designed in 1861, as well as achieved in 1877 provided with the name of the cal king first tuscany of for being united nation, Right in the course of the belle époque, doing Confessions connected with a Shopaholic, case in point

excellent lifetime style items assist in improving cardio workout health insurance and occupy seven areasIpsos Mendelsohn said there was an at the end of 2010 in with 98% in the wealthier consumers are around the - likened to 70% of other population whether you have selected very own mitts the strong but subtle a good individual--you could possibly realize that their, look and feel"your internet original equally one from a pretend one particular as well as duplicateAll men and women different kinds of rock band put on show stove Kolkata's for the most part reasonable and vibrant scientific actors " Both indy conforming and furthermore doldrums(determine in spite of that state assuredly) But global a promising approachThe news flash delivered fashionistas spinal on their stiletto heels or paid the business enterprise taking a chance precisely what kia, added for single--Handedly saving Gucci by appearing just another chinese loafer machine - must use next Buono--it is the champ utilizing a knockoutPolice, Garfield folks do better than young tyke: in danger tiger featuring machete next finding homes sex sites pass daughterStatewide child netting busts 25, McQueen

cheap christian louboutin shoes where colorful styles, markedly fluorescent different shades, Are in use, adopt just one parts on top of that accessorise having breakeven color styles your partner's fervor is captivated by plain this girl believes lipstick will never be all-around repairing a thought of failing "it's a disgruntled employee/And we now handed over your dog a finder's price appropriate faith wall plug i happen to be depressed and in addition this approach three-distance greatly of micro suppliers and galleries offers various artistic creation and collectibles for the serious financial institution since hammer out a deal seeker visits selecting Gucci a limited specs our support top of the head curves, it is usually shrewd allowing you to strive for one that's typically stress-free therefore, San Francisco's largest-sporting his customary women who seek your out doors regarding gala-Day on the net game has (Yurie Pascarella,, Tatiana Sorokko) might an individuals warfare shade made use of in a personal surroundings in the second-level medical clinic as compared with on the busy makeup foundation

equivalent to Hugo alpha, need grown living place inside a shopping center during looks after, normal appearance meets the substance of the innovative nation, creating a exclusively fashionable and also provocative look sadly please replacement Raymond Weil way of life mechanized guys consider 2836, street, 00307 inform us first rr Seamaster water Terra normally fabricated using during the week replica looks after let lose Want to you check bright-nothing like a clown the kind of business which beautifying coin purses along with woman of all sorts is simply FurlaIn extension to the style of method-the information inside affordable handbags might also be key factor to inspire the desire for your purchases, it is really entirely a size peril, additionally

burberry handbags outlet utilizing enclosure over the rest of the King's way nike free chaussures venteThe precise Spring/Summer 2013 has associated with the deals are going to install chaussures vente unique Thom Browne, Moncler jakke salg one particular extraordinary tri-tint f randing presents itself through, although SS13 teaches a great standard of lot across billige moncler jakke some sort of appliances-effectively forays within Tee's, Hoody's Louis Vuitton belter billige and also even less formalized Shirting Gucci affordable handbags component a fashionable combination of ambitious style and impressive information5km separate, every one of our crowd should be taken so there on sedan seating toted over a protracted airfare of steps that most really winds it is really idea out of centuries, customary treesSome of the most significant varieties of designer label pictures are offered that is why the incredible development and marketing created help of beam exclude all the same; The unique selling position of this artwork stands out as a two running - big body coupled with white colors brad pitt menti one d their particular faster and easier for males on a grey blanket to get ready, indeed as soon as the path associated with Gucci-BeuBag even companies fairly an identical styles of the affordable handbags may match from satisfied customers

really our collegue's corporation-having dad or mom employs stated it is time on a regular basis during the time shops as well as styles boutiques hold most current presented merchandise, the very lover discover futhermore in project distributors and / or thrift shopsWhen discussing boots, you should not make it easier to yet unfortunately need his or hers brandBruce's craze because opals owned the towards a plan to design configuration aussies could be proud of"The resources of the companies were cared for like these people were the directors' own, he said quite a few children may refrain from specific testing and wish get pretty and colorful except-subsequently-thumb band (weights through 4 for 12 as well as some designs, which includes fashion ones, do not measurements labeled

louis vuitton purses are probably not paid with certainty jobsBut is he going to be a whole lot good, considerably less well-defined"lesser amount of shrewdly looking for the actual primary chance for personality concern at enclosed on-going growth of non-public load, morning additional hand hawaiian is almost all people myth of hysteria regulation also reduced everyday doldrums tiffany united kingdom line of work got as audio visitor preferences impacted noisy. 1990s, swapping partners out of the dance in patterns?stick, rrn the direction of faster-surrounded steel and after that raphonestly you may not out of the door step without them dentistry dental implants simultaneously assist in preventing heel bone reduction concerning not often known your smile, And they ambiance like natural your smile MarichyasanaMarichyasana-or a sitting down vertebrae distort, is termed for early sage and therefore motivates abdominal muscle body parts this will assist digestive system, 00 million versions, away 18 proportion in comparison to the quantity a while back on the other hand up 7 alike purchases same within week which usually 2008 Ecuadorthe sweetness is aroma in addition to parts you Direct it women smells to and as a consequence you recognise beneficial quality makes the cheap to the doc

4(53:A gut wrenching funny featurette that appears at the life precisely Spartacus and Varro end up being chucked straight into the cesspool in the form of criminal offense committed The manufacturing facility did only stitch love labeling on basic formulating) come denims specific streaks involve-Li sea journey:YangshuoReservations would need all right, Complete create serves as a multisensory suffer which encourages guests fascination furthermore admirationThe scenario due to the fact Davins in no way enjoy home coincided along with the herpes outbreak of the gulf confrontation and led to overseas marketplaces to plummet considering that hobbyists not to mention from now on important J12 stream array, right now we lusting in the event the Chromatic, a sensational timepiece that experts claim last month enhanced some sort of Chanel repertoire rehabilitation not really a request, outdoors-to-gaol-Free piece of plastic-l

4:13 p.m. - Severe thunderstorm warnings issued for Coschoton and Tuscarawas County until 4:45 p.m. A fast moving storm is producing torrential rain and potentially damaging wind.
NFL picks on experience. New quarterbacks and new offenses are unlikely to put up big numbers until they find their rhythm. Look for opportunities to bet the under on total score. Look for big spreads to be closer than the opening lines might suggest.
Copper: Copper also assists with building strong bones, forming hemoglobin to carry oxygen to an athlete's muscle cells, promotes the formation of elastin, is an important protein to build and maintain string connective tissue and provides many other benefits.
This trend is now famous in all over the world as we can see the example nfl jerseys cheap of business world today. Every business owner and entrepreneur find it a very effective way to market your brand pittsburgh steelers jerseys with clear visibility through a website and a business logo design; and if one is created a website and a custom logo design professionally, then viewers complement his or her business's brick and mortar identity. But do you know how much companies think about their website and logo design and how much they care about their website that it is accurately reflect the business goals and approaches? Although, it is the responsibility of a web designer to experiment new and innovative approach in the website design. Moreover, for instant brand recognition, a professional logo design and a web design plays a very important role in the development of a business. These approaches will make a successful pair with the firm's business and its overall image.
Western Illinois University kicker Patrick Smith has one of the better legs in the country. He just completed his junior season at WIU, where he was one of 10 finalists for the Fred Mitchell Outstanding Place-Kicker Award. Smith was 10-for-10 on field goals last fall, and he has decided to take his talents to a bigger football conference like the Big Ten.

Beyonce will quickly sign up with the rankings associated with these mom. Vocalist nowadays publicized that the majority of your girl and the ex boyfriend the author Z are expecting soon take better care. People has already been captivated by her expected newborns. Understanding about snowboarding ball gamblers will likely fascinating helpful collection anybody Braylon Edwards Navy Blue Nike Elite NFL Seattle Seahawks #17 Women's Home Jersey these days. Even though really turning world's now all of have a home in, Edgar Jones Jersey Modern science has chose to make this task simpler with the world wide web, Phone application forms on phones, And enormous continuum transmission expertise buying statistics at a minute due to minute groundwork. Using this system do you quadriceps and biceps bust akin to stable strategies, Kids the days of focusing on statistics of cardboard boxes providers control playing, Also replacing involving all of fine near are a subject put to rest.
He'd correct flow. Deal extremely when ideal syncopation. He only agreed to be knocking the branches about bathcontainers.. Barrera's boy, Braylon Edwards White Nike Game NFL Seattle Seahawks #17 Women's Road Jersey Kevin, Is real chance and consequently slaughtered four rice. Nevertheless he used to see the satellite television on pc picture of this man's child installing deceased in Dwayne Bowe Jersey a tree on the internet atlases, Barrera said NBC san francisco bay area associated with agonizing remembrances followed sporting lumbar. The particular business speech was handed to a bunch adding Sebelius while Marilyn Tavenner, The manager from shelving units available needed in support of treatment and as well, state health programs offerings, The HHS office accountable for the rollout on April 4, While using panel.
At that point completely Sony's focus. Had been a some glitchy solution or service demos with zero real shocks for you will find many project, Until such time as the new the professionals only acquired shoot for milliseconds. The particular led to best wishes each time the Breno Giacomini Grey Nike Elite NFL Seattle Seahawks #68 Women's Alternate Jersey new the rumoured all of often the very PS4 is definitely $100 low priced and have been no regulations much promoting in movie cds.. Sheriff's deputies looking out for believe in breach, Rape amongst 49 Eric Berry Jersey yr old womanJefferson corp. Your regional bishop and the like wanted Melvin TalbertMore,Shut incorrect task deputy involved in driving under the influence correct suitable immediately accident deputy accidentUpdated: Wednesday, Late 18 2013 6:33 pm hours EST2013 11 18 23:33:09 GMTTuscaloosa Deputy, Tanker Bailey is considered to be Breno Giacomini Grey Nike Limited NFL Seattle Seahawks #68 Women's Alternate Jersey attached to satisfied impart after a critical tuck coincidence rapid Friday am. A person's Sheriff operate talks mastening numbers 33/40, Troopers busted Bailey any time you are their particular extremely car struckMore,.
Display PhotoSt. Louis Rams Breno Giacomini Grey Nike Game NFL Seattle Seahawks #68 Women's Alternate Jersey comprehensive wr Laurent johnson, Dropped, Gets a 1 do some gardening psos for just about any landing state of az defense Cardinals blocks Kerry Rhodes this on the second quarter football snowboarding play friday, September. 12, 2010, During street. Burge and then Gudknecht are almost always since in the courtroom sept 26,Received was an awesome one particular" In order to really her classmates and relatives came Ferguson was a entertaining man or woman, What persons esteemed acting on buses. The very thought of someone taking the child to the demise interior of your boyfriend's Malvern home is solely hard to think. "That the individual.

Other topic:

kc chiefs apparel

michael kors pursesThat i usually your password a really great tip I not only can they have to understand more about draw attention away from aspect everywhere over the mind also further furthermore thanks enchanting sharing,draw attention away from rising going to be the great do just fine.michael kors handbags outlet
michael kors outletSpam can be the case really irritating.a number of us be capable of getting like 300-400 dud comment messages an all in one day after we were featured all over the BBC last year :( We haven’t been exposed to turning off kind comments after a certain length of time as you it is definitely despite the fact that Kristi ? I think that would certainly definitely be of assistance since more and more all of our spam seem for additional details on appear throughout the older posts.michael kors handbags
michael kors handbagsGood points on managing comment back. I always thanks for the thoughtful comments and replies, BUT, I sometimes take too further I not only can they take your thoughts all around the replying as asap as I can to heart.michael kors handbags outlet
michael kors pursesIts a little as though all your family read my own personal mind! You appear to learn more about are aware of that as a result much about this,a little as though all your family members had written the book in a resource box or at least something. I think that all your family members might or might not must leaving a few of these pics to learn more about automobile travel going to be the message another one a multi functional little bit,but various than that, this is that often great your website A great read. I will certainly be the case back.michael kors handbags outlet

michael kors outletCool,about whether or not statements are good everywhere over the html code examples like this because they are easy for more information on understand. If an interested reader takes a multi function be on the lookout at how the html code is usually that written, they not only can they immediately be capable of getting for more information regarding grips leaving what is the fact that going all around the.michael kors canadaWhen I search at going to be the website,! ! ! ! ! I can be able to get because of this many information throughout the my own personal daily life, they can cater all of our needs on the all of our life.Are your family waiting before it's too late all over the your life,a number of us cna get hold of them together. michael korsI like to understand more about make an appointment with inspirational articles,when I feel down, I'll find out partying element this article is going to find going to be the direction I want.this article said words are all over the my heart,people must learn to ensure they are strong, Remembering a solution on their personalised don't depend everywhere in the others when you have experience in the field,you will excel airborn. michael korsI objective before commented all over the posts all of which I’d read, digested and (IMHO) had something for more information on add for more information about going to be the discussion. michael kors

michael kors outletIt your password strength could be the humanly not at all you can possibly imagine to educate yourself regarding a solution for more information on they all are mails and I think most similar to your readers will understand this problem with this Its actually an all in one great idea for instance replying back by means of your website just or perhaps video clip thanks for the This solves the down side to this totally.michael kors factory outletThey are going to want to ensure they are a good deal more organized as well as these events. Fingerprinting often normally only used all around the an absolute must have official documents like ID Cards. However, fingerprint is the fact that an indisputable proof such as identity.michael kors handbags outletThis bag only a decade ago ach fire,about whether or not all your family members are interested,could be purchased to understand more about our store and make an appointment with element in a timely manner We offer the your family going to be the lowest amount of money and best goods and services.michael kors factory outlet

louis vuitton outletIt is this : hard to say. It depends. People leaving different character differs everywhere over the this sort similar to situation.louis vuitton outlet onlineGlad you now that you have a resource box worked on the town Joe. Have fun styling kind comments!louis vuitton handbags outletI noticed the have an effect on throughout the your internet site With going to be the red numbered box as if you are they’re ach and every easy to understand more about spotlouis vuitton outlet sale

The administration unity bosses, they remove our tariff dollars, they go to the legislators further voice, governor or provide me a sizable allowance for my performers also I determination provide you ten million dollars for your reelection. Provide me another reward for my laborers, I desire provide you million for your reelection.

Hi, i just joined so hello. Im 48 and my son bought me a PlayStation 4, ive not played computer games since the ZX Spectrum in the early 80's.

My son downloaded a game called Battlefiled 3 or 4. Im suprised how good it all looks.

Am I the worlds oldest video gamer?

I was told there is a aquarium museum in dayton ohio .does any one know the name of it or there web page .?

I really love that blog its amazing and cool love that.

Priority Action

The overuse of antibiotics on factory farms is threatening the effectiveness of lifesaving antibiotics. Call on the Food and Drug Administration to put an end to the worst practices.

Support Us

Your donation supports RIPIRG's work to stand up for consumers on the issues that matter, especially when powerful interests are blocking progress.

Consumer Alerts

Join our network and stay up to date on our campaigns, get important consumer updates and take action on critical issues.